Pre Owned Luxury Jewelry

Looking to make some stylish & affordable additions to the jewelry box? You’ve come to the right place. Find used jewelry from luxury brands like David Yurman, Cartier, Ippolita, Tiffany and more.

All of our pre-owned products are certified authentic. Browse our available fine jewelry selection below and contact us with any questions, or come visit us in-store to check out products in-person. We have two Columbus Ohio locations - Easton and Short North. 

Make this jewelry even more affordable by selling your current collection items for cash or in-store credit. You can learn about our buying process & inquire online.
Pre-Owned John Hardy Bamboo Lava Large HoopsPre-Owned John Hardy Bamboo Lava Large Hoops

John Hardy

Pre-Owned John Hardy Bamboo Lava Large Hoops

$ 297 $ 495
Pre-Owned Tiffany & Co. Return to Tiffany Tag NecklacePre-Owned Tiffany & Co. Return to Tiffany Tag Necklace

Tiffany & Co.

Pre-Owned Tiffany & Co. Return to Tiffany Tag Necklace

$ 330 $ 550
Pre-Owned David Yurman Confetti RingPre-Owned David Yurman Confetti Ring
sold

David Yurman

Pre-Owned David Yurman Confetti Ring

$ 750 $ 1,250
Pre-Owned 30mm Twisted Hoop EarringsPre-Owned 30mm Twisted Hoop Earrings

STORE 5a | Authentic • Pre-owned • Luxury

Pre-Owned 30mm Twisted Hoop Earrings

$ 65 $ 115
Pre-Owned Opal and Diamond RingPre-Owned Opal and Diamond Ring

STORE 5a | Authentic • Pre-owned • Luxury

Pre-Owned Opal and Diamond Ring

$ 1,825 $ 3,660
Pre-Owned David Yurman Albion PendantPre-Owned David Yurman Albion Pendant

David Yurman

Pre-Owned David Yurman Albion Pendant

$ 560 $ 800
Pre-Owned John Hardy Classic Chain BraceletPre-Owned John Hardy Classic Chain Bracelet

John Hardy

Pre-Owned John Hardy Classic Chain Bracelet

$ 850 $ 1,450
Pre-Owned Old Mine Cut Diamond RingPre-Owned Old Mine Cut Diamond Ring

STORE 5a | Authentic • Pre-owned • Luxury

Pre-Owned Old Mine Cut Diamond Ring

$ 1,885 $ 4,750
Pre-Owned Garnet and Diamond EarringsPre-Owned Garnet and Diamond Earrings

STORE 5a | Authentic • Pre-owned • Luxury

Pre-Owned Garnet and Diamond Earrings

$ 1,495 $ 2,995
Pre-Owned Three Stone Diamond PendantPre-Owned Three Stone Diamond Pendant

STORE 5a | Authentic • Pre-owned • Luxury

Pre-Owned Three Stone Diamond Pendant

$ 345 $ 950
Pre-Owned 18" Rope ChainPre-Owned 18" Rope Chain
sold

STORE 5a | Authentic • Pre-owned • Luxury

Pre-Owned 18" Rope Chain

$ 235 $ 470
Pre-Owned Garnet RingPre-Owned Garnet Ring

STORE 5a | Authentic • Pre-owned • Luxury

Pre-Owned Garnet Ring

$ 499 $ 1,295
Pre-Owned Diamond Cluster Stud EarringsPre-Owned Diamond Cluster Stud Earrings

STORE 5a | Authentic • Pre-owned • Luxury

Pre-Owned Diamond Cluster Stud Earrings

$ 825 $ 1,990
Pre-owned David Yurman amethyst Renai braceletPre-owned David Yurman amethyst Renai bracelet

David Yurman

Pre-owned David Yurman amethyst Renai bracelet

$ 1,250 $ 2,090
Pre-Owned Opal and Seed Pearl PendantPre-Owned Opal and Seed Pearl Pendant

STORE 5a | Authentic • Pre-owned • Luxury

Pre-Owned Opal and Seed Pearl Pendant

$ 1,120 $ 2,800
Pre-Owned Sapphire and Diamond RingPre-Owned Sapphire and Diamond Ring

STORE 5a | Authentic • Pre-owned • Luxury

Pre-Owned Sapphire and Diamond Ring

$ 985 $ 1,695
Pre-Owned John Hardy Palu Bulan EnhancerPre-Owned John Hardy Palu Bulan Enhancer

John Hardy

Pre-Owned John Hardy Palu Bulan Enhancer

$ 475 $ 795
Pre-Owned John Hardy Jaisalmer Drop EarringsPre-Owned John Hardy Jaisalmer Drop Earrings

John Hardy

Pre-Owned John Hardy Jaisalmer Drop Earrings

$ 325 $ 650
Pre-Owned John Hardy Diamond Classic Chain BraceletPre-Owned John Hardy Diamond Classic Chain Bracelet

John Hardy

Pre-Owned John Hardy Diamond Classic Chain Bracelet

$ 1,675 $ 2,795
Pre-Owned Tiffany & Co. Elsa Peretti "E" PendantPre-Owned Tiffany & Co. Elsa Peretti "E" Pendant

Tiffany & Co.

Pre-Owned Tiffany & Co. Elsa Peretti "E" Pendant

$ 150 $ 260
Pre-Owned Tiffany & Co. "Return to Tiffany" Circle Tag BraceletPre-Owned Tiffany & Co. "Return to Tiffany" Circle Tag Bracelet

Tiffany & Co.

Pre-Owned Tiffany & Co. "Return to Tiffany" Circle Tag Bracelet

$ 335
Pre-Owned Tiffany & Co. Woven BandPre-Owned Tiffany & Co. Woven Band

Tiffany & Co.

Pre-Owned Tiffany & Co. Woven Band

$ 180 $ 300
Pre-Owned Tahitian Pearl EarringsPre-Owned Tahitian Pearl Earrings

STORE 5a | Authentic • Pre-owned • Luxury

Pre-Owned Tahitian Pearl Earrings

$ 350 $ 980
Pre-Owned Snake ChainPre-Owned Snake Chain
sold

STORE 5a | Authentic • Pre-owned • Luxury

Pre-Owned Snake Chain

$ 240 $ 485
Pre-Owned Mixed Gemstone BraceletPre-Owned Mixed Gemstone Bracelet

STORE 5a | Authentic • Pre-owned • Luxury

Pre-Owned Mixed Gemstone Bracelet

$ 2,225 $ 5,500
Pre-Owned Diamond Dangle EarringsPre-Owned Diamond Dangle Earrings

STORE 5a | Authentic • Pre-owned • Luxury

Pre-Owned Diamond Dangle Earrings

$ 550 $ 1,375
Pre-Owned David Yurman Oval Link NecklacePre-Owned David Yurman Oval Link Necklace

David Yurman

Pre-Owned David Yurman Oval Link Necklace

$ 1,950 $ 2,800
Pre-Owned David Yurman Thoroughbred Shrimp EarringsPre-Owned David Yurman Thoroughbred Shrimp Earrings

David Yurman

Pre-Owned David Yurman Thoroughbred Shrimp Earrings

$ 495 $ 725
Pre-Owned Lagos Arcadia EarringsPre-Owned Lagos Arcadia Earrings

Lagos

Pre-Owned Lagos Arcadia Earrings

$ 310 $ 625
Pre-Owned David Yurman Hematite Albion RingPre-Owned David Yurman Hematite Albion Ring

David Yurman

Pre-Owned David Yurman Hematite Albion Ring

$ 585 $ 975
Pre-Owned Green Chrysoprase EnhancerPre-Owned Green Chrysoprase Enhancer

STORE 5a | Authentic • Pre-owned • Luxury

Pre-Owned Green Chrysoprase Enhancer

$ 1,545 $ 3,400
Pre-Owned Fancy Link ChainPre-Owned Fancy Link Chain

STORE 5a | Authentic • Pre-owned • Luxury

Pre-Owned Fancy Link Chain

$ 199 $ 425
Pre-Owned Three Stone Diamond RingPre-Owned Three Stone Diamond Ring

STORE 5a | Authentic • Pre-owned • Luxury

Pre-Owned Three Stone Diamond Ring

$ 4,299 $ 8,620
Pre-Owned Platinum Huggie EarringsPre-Owned Platinum Huggie Earrings

STORE 5a | Authentic • Pre-owned • Luxury

Pre-Owned Platinum Huggie Earrings

$ 1,100 $ 2,200
Pre-Owned Armenta RingPre-Owned Armenta Ring

Armenta

Pre-Owned Armenta Ring

$ 790 $ 1,580
Pre-Owned Akoya Pearl StrandPre-Owned Akoya Pearl Strand

STORE 5a | Authentic • Pre-owned • Luxury

Pre-Owned Akoya Pearl Strand

$ 2,585 $ 5,690
Pre-Owned Diamond RingPre-Owned Diamond Ring

STORE 5a | Authentic • Pre-owned • Luxury

Pre-Owned Diamond Ring

$ 880 $ 2,220
Pre-Owned Diamond Stud EarringsPre-Owned Diamond Stud Earrings

STORE 5a | Authentic • Pre-owned • Luxury

Pre-Owned Diamond Stud Earrings

$ 835 $ 1,395
Pre-Owned Penny Preville Diamond BanglePre-Owned Penny Preville Diamond Bangle

Penny Preville

Pre-Owned Penny Preville Diamond Bangle

$ 3,995 $ 6,855
Pre-Owned Tiffany & Co. Hardware Ball NecklacePre-Owned Tiffany & Co. Hardware Ball Necklace

Tiffany & Co.

Pre-Owned Tiffany & Co. Hardware Ball Necklace

$ 350 $ 500

Recently viewed