Pre Owned Luxury Jewelry

Find pre-owned jewelry from luxury brands like David Yurman, Cartier, Ippolita, Tiffany, and more. 

Browse our fine jewelry below or at one of our Columbus stores today. Looking to make your purchase more affordable? Learn about our buying services. 
Pre-Owned Tiffany & Co. Return to Tiffany Heart BraceletPre-Owned Tiffany & Co. Return to Tiffany Heart Bracelet

Tiffany & Co.

Pre-Owned Tiffany & Co. Return to Tiffany Heart Bracelet

$ 160 $ 200
Pre-Owned John Hardy Mystic Blue Topaz and Diamond Batu Mata Clip-On EarringsPre-Owned John Hardy Mystic Blue Topaz and Diamond Batu Mata Clip-On Earrings

John Hardy

Pre-Owned John Hardy Mystic Blue Topaz and Diamond Batu Mata Clip-On Earrings

$ 1,325 $ 1,895
Pre-Owned John Hardy Black Sapphire Chain BraceletPre-Owned John Hardy Black Sapphire Chain Bracelet

John Hardy

Pre-Owned John Hardy Black Sapphire Chain Bracelet

$ 350 $ 495
Pre-Owned Lagos Smoky Topaz Mini Glacier EnhancerPre-Owned Lagos Smoky Topaz Mini Glacier Enhancer

Lagos

Pre-Owned Lagos Smoky Topaz Mini Glacier Enhancer

$ 150 $ 275
Pre-Owned Ippolita Clear Quartz Rock Candy EarringsPre-Owned Ippolita Clear Quartz Rock Candy Earrings

Ippolita

Pre-Owned Ippolita Clear Quartz Rock Candy Earrings

$ 550 $ 685
Pre-Owned Tiffany & Co. 1837 Bar PendantPre-Owned Tiffany & Co. 1837 Bar Pendant

Tiffany & Co.

Pre-Owned Tiffany & Co. 1837 Bar Pendant

$ 210 $ 350
Pre-Owned Tiffany & Co. 1837 Cutout BandPre-Owned Tiffany & Co. 1837 Cutout Band

Tiffany & Co.

Pre-Owned Tiffany & Co. 1837 Cutout Band

$ 245 $ 390
Pre-Owned Penny Preville Diamond Lace EnhancerPre-Owned Penny Preville Diamond Lace Enhancer

Penny Preville

Pre-Owned Penny Preville Diamond Lace Enhancer

$ 2,295 $ 2,995
Pre-Owned David Yurman Cable 5-Row CuffPre-Owned David Yurman Cable 5-Row Cuff

David Yurman

Pre-Owned David Yurman Cable 5-Row Cuff

$ 1,495 $ 2,450
Pre-Owned David Yurman Black Onyx and Diamond Wrap PendantPre-Owned David Yurman Black Onyx and Diamond Wrap Pendant
sold

David Yurman

Pre-Owned David Yurman Black Onyx and Diamond Wrap Pendant

$ 540 $ 1,075
Pre-Owned Princess Cut Diamond Stud EarringsPre-Owned Princess Cut Diamond Stud Earrings

STORE 5a Luxury Preowned Goods

Pre-Owned Princess Cut Diamond Stud Earrings

$ 885 $ 1,765
Pre-Owned David Yurman Black Onyx Bijoux EarringsPre-Owned David Yurman Black Onyx Bijoux Earrings

David Yurman

Pre-Owned David Yurman Black Onyx Bijoux Earrings

$ 228 $ 325
Pre-Owned Lagos Caviar Hoop EarringsPre-Owned Lagos Caviar Hoop Earrings

Lagos

Pre-Owned Lagos Caviar Hoop Earrings

$ 325 $ 395
Pre-Owned David Yurman Cable Classic Buckle BraceletPre-Owned David Yurman Cable Classic Buckle Bracelet

David Yurman

Pre-Owned David Yurman Cable Classic Buckle Bracelet

$ 610 $ 795
Pre-Owned David Yurman Citrine RingPre-Owned David Yurman Citrine Ring

David Yurman

Pre-Owned David Yurman Citrine Ring

$ 295 $ 450
Pre-Owned John Hardy Naga Lariat NecklacePre-Owned John Hardy Naga Lariat Necklace

John Hardy

Pre-Owned John Hardy Naga Lariat Necklace

$ 825 $ 1,100
Pre-Owned Penny Preville Diamond Eternity BandPre-Owned Penny Preville Diamond Eternity Band

Penny Preville

Pre-Owned Penny Preville Diamond Eternity Band

$ 6,975 $ 10,155
Pre-Owned Ippolita Large Hammered Dome RingPre-Owned Ippolita Large Hammered Dome Ring

Ippolita

Pre-Owned Ippolita Large Hammered Dome Ring

$ 195 $ 295
Pre-Owned John Hardy Dot BraceletPre-Owned John Hardy Dot Bracelet

John Hardy

Pre-Owned John Hardy Dot Bracelet

$ 555 $ 695
Pre-Owned Tiffany & Co. Multi-Strand Heart Toggle NecklacePre-Owned Tiffany & Co. Multi-Strand Heart Toggle Necklace

Tiffany & Co.

Pre-Owned Tiffany & Co. Multi-Strand Heart Toggle Necklace

$ 350 $ 525
Pre-Owned Ippolita Wonderland Mint Teardrop EarringsPre-Owned Ippolita Wonderland Mint Teardrop Earrings
sold

Ippolita

Pre-Owned Ippolita Wonderland Mint Teardrop Earrings

$ 310 $ 395
Pre-Owned Ippolita Pearl Link NecklacePre-Owned Ippolita Pearl Link Necklace

Ippolita

Pre-Owned Ippolita Pearl Link Necklace

$ 675 $ 1,355
Pre-Owned Tiffany & Co. Atlas Clip-On EarringsPre-Owned Tiffany & Co. Atlas Clip-On Earrings

Tiffany & Co.

Pre-Owned Tiffany & Co. Atlas Clip-On Earrings

$ 325 $ 750
Pre-Owned David Yurman Diamond Hinged BanglePre-Owned David Yurman Diamond Hinged Bangle

David Yurman

Pre-Owned David Yurman Diamond Hinged Bangle

$ 1,245 $ 1,995
Pre-Owned Lagos Golden Obsidian Bead BraceletPre-Owned Lagos Golden Obsidian Bead Bracelet
sold

Lagos

Pre-Owned Lagos Golden Obsidian Bead Bracelet

$ 190 $ 225
Pre-Owned Fancy Twisted ChainPre-Owned Fancy Twisted Chain

STORE 5a Luxury Preowned Goods

Pre-Owned Fancy Twisted Chain

$ 300 $ 430
Pre-Owned David Yurman Sculpted Cable RingPre-Owned David Yurman Sculpted Cable Ring
sold

David Yurman

Pre-Owned David Yurman Sculpted Cable Ring

$ 315 $ 425
Pre-Owned David Yurman Pearl and Diamond NecklacePre-Owned David Yurman Pearl and Diamond Necklace

David Yurman

Pre-Owned David Yurman Pearl and Diamond Necklace

$ 1,515 $ 1,900
Pre-Owned S-Link ChainPre-Owned S-Link Chain

STORE 5a Luxury Preowned Goods

Pre-Owned S-Link Chain

$ 285 $ 400
Pre-Owned Ippolita Blue Topaz BanglePre-Owned Ippolita Blue Topaz Bangle

Ippolita

Pre-Owned Ippolita Blue Topaz Bangle

$ 230 $ 375
Pre-Owned Cartier Love RingPre-Owned Cartier Love Ring

Cartier

Pre-Owned Cartier Love Ring

$ 3,295 $ 3,800
Pre-Owned Tacori Smoky Quartz Round Color Medley NecklacePre-Owned Tacori Smoky Quartz Round Color Medley Necklace

STORE 5a Luxury Preowned Goods

Pre-Owned Tacori Smoky Quartz Round Color Medley Necklace

$ 290 $ 350
Pre-Owned Italian Coin RingPre-Owned Italian Coin Ring

STORE 5a Luxury Preowned Goods

Pre-Owned Italian Coin Ring

$ 950 $ 1,900
Pre-Owned John Hardy Square Jaisalmer Dot RingPre-Owned John Hardy Square Jaisalmer Dot Ring

John Hardy

Pre-Owned John Hardy Square Jaisalmer Dot Ring

$ 375 $ 595
Pre-Owned Gucci Ghost Link BraceletPre-Owned Gucci Ghost Link Bracelet

Gucci

Pre-Owned Gucci Ghost Link Bracelet

$ 325 $ 365
Pre-Owned Diamond Stud EarringsPre-Owned Diamond Stud Earrings

STORE 5a Luxury Preowned Goods

Pre-Owned Diamond Stud Earrings

$ 175 $ 295
Pre-Owned Diamond Earring JacketsPre-Owned Diamond Earring Jackets

STORE 5a Luxury Preowned Goods

Pre-Owned Diamond Earring Jackets

$ 575 $ 985
Pre-Owned Diamond Horseshoe RingPre-Owned Diamond Horseshoe Ring

STORE 5a Luxury Preowned Goods

Pre-Owned Diamond Horseshoe Ring

$ 748 $ 1,495
Pre-Owned Diamond Zipper NecklacePre-Owned Diamond Zipper Necklace
sold

STORE 5a Luxury Preowned Goods

Pre-Owned Diamond Zipper Necklace

$ 13,350 $ 22,300
Pre-Owned David Yurman Black Diamond Wave Cross EnhancerPre-Owned David Yurman Black Diamond Wave Cross Enhancer

David Yurman

Pre-Owned David Yurman Black Diamond Wave Cross Enhancer

$ 1,390 $ 1,855

Recently viewed