Pre Owned Luxury Jewelry

Looking to make some stylish & affordable additions to the jewelry box? You’ve come to the right place. Find used jewelry from luxury brands like David Yurman, Cartier, Ippolita, Tiffany and more.

All of our pre-owned products are certified authentic. Browse our available fine jewelry selection below and contact us with any questions, or come visit us in-store to check out products in-person. We have two Columbus Ohio locations - Easton and Short North. 

Make this jewelry even more affordable by selling your current collection items for cash or in-store credit. You can learn about our buying process & inquire online.
PRE-OWNED DAVID YURMAN TORCH EARRINGSPRE-OWNED DAVID YURMAN TORCH EARRINGS

David Yurman

PRE-OWNED DAVID YURMAN TORCH EARRINGS

$ 750 $ 1,250
PRE-OWNED STERLING SILVER & 18KRG TACORI LINK BRACELET PRE-OWNED STERLING SILVER & 18KRG TACORI LINK BRACELET 

Tacori

PRE-OWNED STERLING SILVER & 18KRG TACORI LINK BRACELET 

$ 535 $ 1,070
Pre-owned tanzanite ringPre-owned tanzanite ring

STORE 5a | Authentic • Pre-owned • Luxury

Pre-owned tanzanite ring

$ 90 $ 195
Pre-Owned Tiffany & Co. "F" CharmPre-Owned Tiffany & Co. "F" Charm

Tiffany & Co.

Pre-Owned Tiffany & Co. "F" Charm

$ 75 $ 140
Pre-owned David Yurman amethyst and diamond braceletPre-owned David Yurman amethyst and diamond bracelet

David Yurman

Pre-owned David Yurman amethyst and diamond bracelet

$ 995 $ 1,900
Pre-owned John Hardy Rudraksha bead braceletPre-owned John Hardy Rudraksha bead bracelet

John Hardy

Pre-owned John Hardy Rudraksha bead bracelet

$ 175 $ 295
Pre-owned David Yurman black onyx and diamond enhancerPre-owned David Yurman black onyx and diamond enhancer

David Yurman

Pre-owned David Yurman black onyx and diamond enhancer

$ 735 $ 1,475
Pre-owned Peace Sign pendantPre-owned Peace Sign pendant

STORE 5a | Authentic • Pre-owned • Luxury

Pre-owned Peace Sign pendant

$ 435 $ 725
Pre-owned hoopsPre-owned hoops

STORE 5a | Authentic • Pre-owned • Luxury

Pre-owned hoops

$ 225 $ 399
Pre-owned Tiffany & Company Infinity Double Chain necklacePre-owned Tiffany & Company Infinity Double Chain necklace

Tiffany & Co.

Pre-owned Tiffany & Company Infinity Double Chain necklace

$ 165 $ 275
Pre-owned David Yurman Albion ringPre-owned David Yurman Albion ring

David Yurman

Pre-owned David Yurman Albion ring

$ 630 $ 1,050
Pre-owned Diamond PendantPre-owned Diamond Pendant

STORE 5a | Authentic • Pre-owned • Luxury

Pre-owned Diamond Pendant

$ 695 $ 2,000
Pre-owned Aquamarine StudsPre-owned Aquamarine Studs

STORE 5a | Authentic • Pre-owned • Luxury

Pre-owned Aquamarine Studs

$ 1,575 $ 3,150
Pre-owned Tourmaline and Diamond ringPre-owned Tourmaline and Diamond ring

STORE 5a | Authentic • Pre-owned • Luxury

Pre-owned Tourmaline and Diamond ring

$ 4,485 $ 8,975
Pre-owned black onyx ringPre-owned black onyx ring

STORE 5a | Authentic • Pre-owned • Luxury

Pre-owned black onyx ring

$ 145 $ 290
Pre-owned Tiffany & Co 1837 bandPre-owned Tiffany & Co 1837 band

Tiffany & Co.

Pre-owned Tiffany & Co 1837 band

$ 150 $ 245
Pre-owned San Marco braceletPre-owned San Marco bracelet

STORE 5a | Authentic • Pre-owned • Luxury

Pre-owned San Marco bracelet

$ 725 $ 1,650
Pre-owned banglePre-owned bangle
sold

STORE 5a | Authentic • Pre-owned • Luxury

Pre-owned bangle

$ 45 $ 125
Pre-owned oval hoopsPre-owned oval hoops

STORE 5a | Authentic • Pre-owned • Luxury

Pre-owned oval hoops

$ 175 $ 395
Pre-owned Black Onyx RingPre-owned Black Onyx Ring

STORE 5a | Authentic • Pre-owned • Luxury

Pre-owned Black Onyx Ring

$ 225 $ 595
Pre-owned box link chainPre-owned box link chain

STORE 5a | Authentic • Pre-owned • Luxury

Pre-owned box link chain

$ 95 $ 170
Pre-owned Scott Kay necklacePre-owned Scott Kay necklace

Scott Kay

Pre-owned Scott Kay necklace

$ 810 $ 1,350
Pre-owned Diamond Sun pendantPre-owned Diamond Sun pendant

STORE 5a | Authentic • Pre-owned • Luxury

Pre-owned Diamond Sun pendant

$ 895 $ 2,100
Pre-owned Lagos Heart of Philly braceletPre-owned Lagos Heart of Philly bracelet

Lagos

Pre-owned Lagos Heart of Philly bracelet

$ 125 $ 250
Pre-owned Amethyst and Diamond RingPre-owned Amethyst and Diamond Ring

STORE 5a | Authentic • Pre-owned • Luxury

Pre-owned Amethyst and Diamond Ring

$ 495 $ 1,040
Pre-owned Gucci Horsebit EarringsPre-owned Gucci Horsebit Earrings

Gucci

Pre-owned Gucci Horsebit Earrings

$ 2,895 $ 5,900
Pre-owned green quartz enhancerPre-owned green quartz enhancer

STORE 5a | Authentic • Pre-owned • Luxury

Pre-owned green quartz enhancer

$ 225 $ 595
Pre-owned Chanel CC Coin earringsPre-owned Chanel CC Coin earrings
sold

Chanel

Pre-owned Chanel CC Coin earrings

$ 195
Pre-owned David Yurman Chatelaine Gem NecklacePre-owned David Yurman Chatelaine Gem Necklace

David Yurman

Pre-owned David Yurman Chatelaine Gem Necklace

$ 1,500 $ 2,500
Pre-owned Tiffany & Co “Return to Tiffany” heart tag chokerPre-owned Tiffany & Co “Return to Tiffany” heart tag choker

Tiffany & Co.

Pre-owned Tiffany & Co “Return to Tiffany” heart tag choker

$ 299 $ 525
Pre-owned diamond studsPre-owned diamond studs

STORE 5a | Authentic • Pre-owned • Luxury

Pre-owned diamond studs

$ 625 $ 1,170
Pre-owned David Yurman Wheat chainPre-owned David Yurman Wheat chain

David Yurman

Pre-owned David Yurman Wheat chain

$ 998 $ 1,690
Pre-owned Tiffany & Co. 1837 bandPre-owned Tiffany & Co. 1837 band

Tiffany & Co.

Pre-owned Tiffany & Co. 1837 band

$ 150 $ 245
Pre-owned John Hardy Dot Nuansa Coil BraceletPre-owned John Hardy Dot Nuansa Coil Bracelet

John Hardy

Pre-owned John Hardy Dot Nuansa Coil Bracelet

$ 398 $ 795
Pre-owned Diamond NecklacePre-owned Diamond Necklace

STORE 5a | Authentic • Pre-owned • Luxury

Pre-owned Diamond Necklace

$ 3,250 $ 6,500
Pre-owned David Yurman Double Wheat chainPre-owned David Yurman Double Wheat chain

David Yurman

Pre-owned David Yurman Double Wheat chain

$ 570 $ 950
Pre-owned John Hardy Classic Chain braceletPre-owned John Hardy Classic Chain bracelet

John Hardy

Pre-owned John Hardy Classic Chain bracelet

$ 330 $ 550
Pre-owned Tiffany & Co. Elsa Peretti heart charmPre-owned Tiffany & Co. Elsa Peretti heart charm

Tiffany & Co.

Pre-owned Tiffany & Co. Elsa Peretti heart charm

$ 75 $ 215
Pre-owned David Yurman black onyx Albion ringPre-owned David Yurman black onyx Albion ring

David Yurman

Pre-owned David Yurman black onyx Albion ring

$ 375 $ 625
Pre-owned Ippolita clear quartz pendantPre-owned Ippolita clear quartz pendant
sold

Ippolita

Pre-owned Ippolita clear quartz pendant

$ 297 $ 495

Recently viewed