Pre Owned Fine Jewelry

Looking to make some stylish & affordable additions to the jewelry box? You’ve come to the right place. Find pre-owned jewelry from luxury brands like David Yurman, Cartier, Ippolita, Tiffany and more.

All of our pre-owned products are certified authentic. Browse our available fine jewelry selection below and contact us with any questions, or come visit us in-store to check out products in-person. We have two Columbus Ohio locations - Easton and Short North. 

Make this jewelry even more affordable by selling your current collection items for cash or in-store credit. You can learn about our buying process & inquire online.
Pre-owned Diamond and Garnet ringPre-owned Diamond and Garnet ring

STORE 5a | Authentic • Pre-owned • Luxury

Pre-owned Diamond and Garnet ring

$ 1,225 $ 2,750
Pre-owned Turquoise braceletPre-owned Turquoise bracelet

STORE 5a | Authentic • Pre-owned • Luxury

Pre-owned Turquoise bracelet

$ 495 $ 990
Pre-owned Oval Chalcedony RingPre-owned Oval Chalcedony Ring

STORE 5a | Authentic • Pre-owned • Luxury

Pre-owned Oval Chalcedony Ring

$ 915 $ 2,275
Pre-owned David Yurman Hampton Topaz and Diamond ringPre-owned David Yurman Hampton Topaz and Diamond ring

David Yurman

Pre-owned David Yurman Hampton Topaz and Diamond ring

$ 775 $ 1,150
Pre-owned Marco Bicego Jaipur double drop earringsPre-owned Marco Bicego Jaipur double drop earrings

Marco Bicego

Pre-owned Marco Bicego Jaipur double drop earrings

$ 975 $ 1,450
Pre-owned David Yurman Cable cuffPre-owned David Yurman Cable cuff
sold

David Yurman

Pre-owned David Yurman Cable cuff

$ 275 $ 395
Pre-owned John Hardy Batu Bedeg Eletroform ringPre-owned John Hardy Batu Bedeg Eletroform ring

John Hardy

Pre-owned John Hardy Batu Bedeg Eletroform ring

$ 350 $ 595
Pre-owned David Yurman Smoky Quartz and Diamond Albion ringPre-owned David Yurman Smoky Quartz and Diamond Albion ring

David Yurman

Pre-owned David Yurman Smoky Quartz and Diamond Albion ring

$ 1,212 $ 2,425
Pre-owned Tiffany & Company 1837 Bar pendantPre-owned Tiffany & Company 1837 Bar pendant
sold

Tiffany & Co.

Pre-owned Tiffany & Company 1837 Bar pendant

$ 180 $ 300
Pre-owned Tiffany & Company Notes disc braceletPre-owned Tiffany & Company Notes disc bracelet
sold

Tiffany & Co.

Pre-owned Tiffany & Company Notes disc bracelet

$ 186 $ 310
Pre-owned David Yurman pearl drop pendantPre-owned David Yurman pearl drop pendant

David Yurman

Pre-owned David Yurman pearl drop pendant

$ 525 $ 875
Pre-owned David Yurman Citrine and Diamond Albion pendantPre-owned David Yurman Citrine and Diamond Albion pendant

David Yurman

Pre-owned David Yurman Citrine and Diamond Albion pendant

$ 450 $ 750
Pre-owned Pearl and Diamond RingPre-owned Pearl and Diamond Ring

STORE 5a | Authentic • Pre-owned • Luxury

Pre-owned Pearl and Diamond Ring

$ 299 $ 695
Pre-owned Lapis PendantPre-owned Lapis Pendant

STORE 5a | Authentic • Pre-owned • Luxury

Pre-owned Lapis Pendant

$ 695 $ 1,150
Pre-owned David Yurman Waves braceletPre-owned David Yurman Waves bracelet

David Yurman

Pre-owned David Yurman Waves bracelet

$ 225 $ 375
Pre-owned Three Stone Diamond ringPre-owned Three Stone Diamond ring

STORE 5a | Authentic • Pre-owned • Luxury

Pre-owned Three Stone Diamond ring

$ 5,390 $ 10,650
Pre-owned Diamond EarringsPre-owned Diamond Earrings

STORE 5a | Authentic • Pre-owned • Luxury

Pre-owned Diamond Earrings

$ 2,550 $ 5,100
Pre-owned Judith Ripka Pearl and Black Onyx necklacePre-owned Judith Ripka Pearl and Black Onyx necklace

Judith Ripka

Pre-owned Judith Ripka Pearl and Black Onyx necklace

$ 1,450 $ 2,420
Pre-owned Diamond PendantPre-owned Diamond Pendant

STORE 5a | Authentic • Pre-owned • Luxury

Pre-owned Diamond Pendant

$ 1,920 $ 2,740
Pre-owned Louis Vuitton Logomania necklacePre-owned Louis Vuitton Logomania necklace
sold

Louis Vuitton

Pre-owned Louis Vuitton Logomania necklace

$ 199 $ 405
Pre-owned Diamond Stud EarringsPre-owned Diamond Stud Earrings

STORE 5a | Authentic • Pre-owned • Luxury

Pre-owned Diamond Stud Earrings

$ 2,525 $ 5,075
Pre-owned Stephen Webster Thorn Link braceletPre-owned Stephen Webster Thorn Link bracelet

Stephen Webster

Pre-owned Stephen Webster Thorn Link bracelet

$ 499 $ 950
Pre-owned John Hardy Kali Overlap cuffPre-owned John Hardy Kali Overlap cuff

John Hardy

Pre-owned John Hardy Kali Overlap cuff

$ 695 $ 1,195
Pre-owned Black Diamond and Diamond pendantPre-owned Black Diamond and Diamond pendant

STORE 5a | Authentic • Pre-owned • Luxury

Pre-owned Black Diamond and Diamond pendant

$ 400 $ 800
Pre-owned $20 Gold Coin necklacePre-owned $20 Gold Coin necklace
sold

STORE 5a | Authentic • Pre-owned • Luxury

Pre-owned $20 Gold Coin necklace

$ 1,255 $ 3,970
Pre-owned Marco Bicego Lunaria pendantPre-owned Marco Bicego Lunaria pendant

Marco Bicego

Pre-owned Marco Bicego Lunaria pendant

$ 825 $ 1,440
Pre-owned David Yurman heart broochPre-owned David Yurman heart brooch

David Yurman

Pre-owned David Yurman heart brooch

$ 750 $ 1,250
Pre-owned Pink Tourmaline and Diamond RingPre-owned Pink Tourmaline and Diamond Ring

Diamond Cellar

Pre-owned Pink Tourmaline and Diamond Ring

$ 1,795 $ 3,100
Pre-owned David Yurman Metro hoopsPre-owned David Yurman Metro hoops

David Yurman

Pre-owned David Yurman Metro hoops

$ 475 $ 795
Pre-owned David Yurman Pearl Cookie StudsPre-owned David Yurman Pearl Cookie Studs

David Yurman

Pre-owned David Yurman Pearl Cookie Studs

$ 265 $ 450
Pre-owned David Yurman Diamond Wheat ChainPre-owned David Yurman Diamond Wheat Chain

David Yurman

Pre-owned David Yurman Diamond Wheat Chain

$ 1,800 $ 3,000
Pre-owned David Yurman Buckle ringPre-owned David Yurman Buckle ring

David Yurman

Pre-owned David Yurman Buckle ring

$ 399 $ 695
Pre-owned Blue Quartz EarringsPre-owned Blue Quartz Earrings

STORE 5a | Authentic • Pre-owned • Luxury

Pre-owned Blue Quartz Earrings

$ 235 $ 395
Pre-owned Emerald and Diamond fashion ringPre-owned Emerald and Diamond fashion ring

STORE 5a | Authentic • Pre-owned • Luxury

Pre-owned Emerald and Diamond fashion ring

$ 895 $ 2,175
Pre-owned David Yurman Carnelian necklacePre-owned David Yurman Carnelian necklace

David Yurman

Pre-owned David Yurman Carnelian necklace

$ 435 $ 795
Pre-owned Pearl and Diamond RingPre-owned Pearl and Diamond Ring

STORE 5a | Authentic • Pre-owned • Luxury

Pre-owned Pearl and Diamond Ring

$ 6,350 $ 12,700
Pre-owned diamond hoop earringsPre-owned diamond hoop earrings

STORE 5a | Authentic • Pre-owned • Luxury

Pre-owned diamond hoop earrings

$ 6,600 $ 11,000
Pre-owned Red Glass ringPre-owned Red Glass ring

STORE 5a | Authentic • Pre-owned • Luxury

Pre-owned Red Glass ring

$ 50 $ 79
Pre-owned David Yurman Pearl necklacePre-owned David Yurman Pearl necklace

David Yurman

Pre-owned David Yurman Pearl necklace

$ 1,250 $ 2,250
Pre-owned Roberto Coin Capri hoop earringsPre-owned Roberto Coin Capri hoop earrings

Roberto Coin

Pre-owned Roberto Coin Capri hoop earrings

$ 315 $ 530

Recently viewed