Pre Owned Luxury Jewelry

Looking to make some stylish & affordable additions to the jewelry box? You’ve come to the right place. Find used jewelry from luxury brands like David Yurman, Cartier, Ippolita, Tiffany and more.

All of our pre-owned products are certified authentic. Browse our available fine jewelry selection below and contact us with any questions, or come visit us in-store to check out products in-person. We have two Columbus Ohio locations - Easton and Short North. 

Make this jewelry even more affordable by selling your current collection items for cash or in-store credit. You can learn about our buying process & inquire online.
Pre-owned Tiffany & Co. Sapphire RingPre-owned Tiffany & Co. Sapphire Ring

Tiffany & Co.

Pre-owned Tiffany & Co. Sapphire Ring

$ 350 $ 650
Pre-owned Sapphire and Diamond banglePre-owned Sapphire and Diamond bangle

STORE 5a | Authentic • Pre-owned • Luxury

Pre-owned Sapphire and Diamond bangle

$ 785 $ 1,970
Pre-owned lapis lazuli earringsPre-owned lapis lazuli earrings

STORE 5a | Authentic • Pre-owned • Luxury

Pre-owned lapis lazuli earrings

$ 225 $ 495
Pre-owned lavender jade braceletPre-owned lavender jade bracelet

STORE 5a | Authentic • Pre-owned • Luxury

Pre-owned lavender jade bracelet

$ 499 $ 895
Pre-owned pearl and garnet earringsPre-owned pearl and garnet earrings

STORE 5a | Authentic • Pre-owned • Luxury

Pre-owned pearl and garnet earrings

$ 895 $ 2,050
Pre-owned Robert L. Morris braceletPre-owned Robert L. Morris bracelet

Robert Lee Morris

Pre-owned Robert L. Morris bracelet

$ 299 $ 625
Pre-owned 32mm hoopsPre-owned 32mm hoops

STORE 5a | Authentic • Pre-owned • Luxury

Pre-owned 32mm hoops

$ 155 $ 265
Pre-owned Effy diamond ringPre-owned Effy diamond ring

Effy

Pre-owned Effy diamond ring

$ 1,050 $ 2,600
Pre-owned diamond circle pendantPre-owned diamond circle pendant

STORE 5a | Authentic • Pre-owned • Luxury

Pre-owned diamond circle pendant

$ 295 $ 595
Pre-owned diamond pendantPre-owned diamond pendant

STORE 5a | Authentic • Pre-owned • Luxury

Pre-owned diamond pendant

$ 495 $ 1,195
Pre-owned Tiffany & Co. Elsa Peretti pearl earringsPre-owned Tiffany & Co. Elsa Peretti pearl earrings
sold

Tiffany & Co.

Pre-owned Tiffany & Co. Elsa Peretti pearl earrings

$ 330 $ 475
Pre-owned pink tourmaline ringPre-owned pink tourmaline ring

STORE 5a | Authentic • Pre-owned • Luxury

Pre-owned pink tourmaline ring

$ 750 $ 1,800
Pre-owned Tiffany & Co. Paloma Picasso bar pendantPre-owned Tiffany & Co. Paloma Picasso bar pendant

Tiffany & Co.

Pre-owned Tiffany & Co. Paloma Picasso bar pendant

$ 305 $ 495
Pre-owned cuffPre-owned cuff

STORE 5a | Authentic • Pre-owned • Luxury

Pre-owned cuff

$ 1,850 $ 4,500
Pre-owned diamond stud earringsPre-owned diamond stud earrings

STORE 5a | Authentic • Pre-owned • Luxury

Pre-owned diamond stud earrings

$ 895 $ 1,990
Pre-owned Tiffany & Co. “Return To Tiffany” Heart Tag bead braceletPre-owned Tiffany & Co. “Return To Tiffany” Heart Tag bead bracelet
sold

Tiffany & Co.

Pre-owned Tiffany & Co. “Return To Tiffany” Heart Tag bead bracelet

$ 123 $ 165
Pre-owned diamond heart pendantPre-owned diamond heart pendant

STORE 5a | Authentic • Pre-owned • Luxury

Pre-owned diamond heart pendant

$ 235 $ 595
Pre-owned Tiffany & Co. Elsa Peretti open heart ringPre-owned Tiffany & Co. Elsa Peretti open heart ring

Tiffany & Co.

Pre-owned Tiffany & Co. Elsa Peretti open heart ring

$ 155 $ 260
Pre-owned David Yurman blue topaz earringsPre-owned David Yurman blue topaz earrings
sold

David Yurman

Pre-owned David Yurman blue topaz earrings

$ 285 $ 475
Pre-owned David Yurman amethyst Renai braceletPre-owned David Yurman amethyst Renai bracelet

David Yurman

Pre-owned David Yurman amethyst Renai bracelet

$ 1,250 $ 2,090
Pre-owned Ruby and Diamond RingPre-owned Ruby and Diamond Ring

STORE 5a | Authentic • Pre-owned • Luxury

Pre-owned Ruby and Diamond Ring

$ 895 $ 2,550
Pre-owned Ruby and Diamond banglePre-owned Ruby and Diamond bangle

STORE 5a | Authentic • Pre-owned • Luxury

Pre-owned Ruby and Diamond bangle

$ 795 $ 2,045
Pre-owned loop earringsPre-owned loop earrings

STORE 5a | Authentic • Pre-owned • Luxury

Pre-owned loop earrings

$ 295 $ 775
Pre-owned emerald and diamond pendantPre-owned emerald and diamond pendant

STORE 5a | Authentic • Pre-owned • Luxury

Pre-owned emerald and diamond pendant

$ 1,830 $ 3,945
Pre-owned Lagos citrine pendantPre-owned Lagos citrine pendant

Lagos

Pre-owned Lagos citrine pendant

$ 485 $ 970
Pre-owned doublet ringPre-owned doublet ring

STORE 5a | Authentic • Pre-owned • Luxury

Pre-owned doublet ring

$ 1,045 $ 2,495
Pre-owned Diamond RingPre-owned Diamond Ring

STORE 5a | Authentic • Pre-owned • Luxury

Pre-owned Diamond Ring

$ 2,125 $ 4,840
Pre-owned David Yurman ringPre-owned David Yurman ring

David Yurman

Pre-owned David Yurman ring

$ 395 $ 790
Pre-owned wide woven bandPre-owned wide woven band

STORE 5a | Authentic • Pre-owned • Luxury

Pre-owned wide woven band

$ 295 $ 775
Pre-owned David Yurman black onyx cuffPre-owned David Yurman black onyx cuff
sold

David Yurman

Pre-owned David Yurman black onyx cuff

$ 825 $ 1,650
Pre-owned Tiffany & Co. Heart/Key locketPre-owned Tiffany & Co. Heart/Key locket

Tiffany & Co.

Pre-owned Tiffany & Co. Heart/Key locket

$ 995 $ 1,750
Pre-owned Diamond BraceletPre-owned Diamond Bracelet

STORE 5a | Authentic • Pre-owned • Luxury

Pre-owned Diamond Bracelet

$ 1,645 $ 3,290
Pre-owned Tiffany & Co. “Return To Tiffany” Tag necklacePre-owned Tiffany & Co. “Return To Tiffany” Tag necklace

Tiffany & Co.

Pre-owned Tiffany & Co. “Return To Tiffany” Tag necklace

$ 420 $ 700
Pre-owned box link chainPre-owned box link chain
sold

STORE 5a | Authentic • Pre-owned • Luxury

Pre-owned box link chain

$ 99 $ 225
Pre-owned John Hardy pearl enhancerPre-owned John Hardy pearl enhancer
sold

John Hardy

Pre-owned John Hardy pearl enhancer

$ 175 $ 395
Pre-owned Tiffany & CO. “Return To Tiffany” oval tag chokerPre-owned Tiffany & CO. “Return To Tiffany” oval tag choker

Tiffany & Co.

Pre-owned Tiffany & CO. “Return To Tiffany” oval tag choker

$ 260 $ 525
Pre-owned Hermes HAPI 3 Tripple Tour braceletPre-owned Hermes HAPI 3 Tripple Tour bracelet

Hermes

Pre-owned Hermes HAPI 3 Tripple Tour bracelet

$ 225 $ 350
Pre-owned David Yurman Metro bandPre-owned David Yurman Metro band

David Yurman

Pre-owned David Yurman Metro band

$ 415 $ 695
Pre-owned Tiffany & Co. Atlas cuffPre-owned Tiffany & Co. Atlas cuff

Tiffany & Co.

Pre-owned Tiffany & Co. Atlas cuff

$ 265 $ 450
Pre-Owned Test ProductPre-Owned Test Product

David Yurman

Pre-Owned Test Product

$ 0

Recently viewed