Pre Owned Luxury Jewelry

Find pre-owned jewelry from luxury brands like David Yurman, Cartier, Ippolita, Tiffany, and more. 

Browse our fine jewelry below or at one of our Columbus stores today. Looking to make your purchase more affordable? Learn about our buying services. 
Pre-Owned Pearl and Diamond BraceletPre-Owned Pearl and Diamond Bracelet

Store 5a Luxury Preowned Goods

Pre-Owned Pearl and Diamond Bracelet

$ 275 $ 635
Pre-Owned Citrine Heart and Sapphire Bead NecklacePre-Owned Citrine Heart and Sapphire Bead Necklace

Store 5a Luxury Preowned Goods

Pre-Owned Citrine Heart and Sapphire Bead Necklace

$ 585 $ 975
Pre-Owned David Yurman Dome EarringsPre-Owned David Yurman Dome Earrings

David Yurman

Pre-Owned David Yurman Dome Earrings

$ 450 $ 975
Pre-Owned Lagos Two-Tone Stud EarringsPre-Owned Lagos Two-Tone Stud Earrings
sold

Lagos

Pre-Owned Lagos Two-Tone Stud Earrings

$ 135 $ 195
Pre-Owned Tiffany & Co. Infinity RingPre-Owned Tiffany & Co. Infinity Ring

Tiffany & Co.

Pre-Owned Tiffany & Co. Infinity Ring

$ 165 $ 275
Pre-Owned Diamond Fashion RingPre-Owned Diamond Fashion Ring

Store 5a Luxury Preowned Goods

Pre-Owned Diamond Fashion Ring

$ 300 $ 750
Pre-Owned Diamond BanglePre-Owned Diamond Bangle

Store 5a Luxury Preowned Goods

Pre-Owned Diamond Bangle

$ 625 $ 1,550
Pre-Owned Round Brilliant Diamond PendantPre-Owned Round Brilliant Diamond Pendant

Store 5a Luxury Preowned Goods

Pre-Owned Round Brilliant Diamond Pendant

$ 1,900 $ 3,800
Pre-Owned Wide Diamond BandPre-Owned Wide Diamond Band

Store 5a Luxury Preowned Goods

Pre-Owned Wide Diamond Band

$ 5,150 $ 8,600
Pre-Owned Elizabeth Locke Cheerio Swinging Topknot EarringsPre-Owned Elizabeth Locke Cheerio Swinging Topknot Earrings

ELIZABETH LOCKE

Pre-Owned Elizabeth Locke Cheerio Swinging Topknot Earrings

$ 2,550 $ 4,725
Pre-Owned David Yurman Champagne Citrine and Diamond Albion EnhancerPre-Owned David Yurman Champagne Citrine and Diamond Albion Enhancer

David Yurman

Pre-Owned David Yurman Champagne Citrine and Diamond Albion Enhancer

$ 420 $ 1,050
Pre-Owned Penny Preville Diamond BraceletPre-Owned Penny Preville Diamond Bracelet

Penny Preville

Pre-Owned Penny Preville Diamond Bracelet

$ 4,825 $ 8,175
Pre-Owned Penny Preville Diamond NecklacePre-Owned Penny Preville Diamond Necklace

Penny Preville

Pre-Owned Penny Preville Diamond Necklace

$ 1,875 $ 3,750
Pre-Owned David Yurman Small Box Link ChainPre-Owned David Yurman Small Box Link Chain
sold

David Yurman

Pre-Owned David Yurman Small Box Link Chain

$ 158 $ 225
Pre-Owned David Yurman Medium Oval Link BraceletPre-Owned David Yurman Medium Oval Link Bracelet
sold

David Yurman

Pre-Owned David Yurman Medium Oval Link Bracelet

$ 245 $ 350
Pre-Owned Tiffany & Co. Rubedo 1837 RingPre-Owned Tiffany & Co. Rubedo 1837 Ring

Tiffany & Co.

Pre-Owned Tiffany & Co. Rubedo 1837 Ring

$ 325 $ 465
Pre-Owned Cartier Love RingPre-Owned Cartier Love Ring
sold

Cartier

Pre-Owned Cartier Love Ring

$ 1,395 $ 1,720
Pre-Owned David Yurman Smoky Quartz and Diamond Albion RingPre-Owned David Yurman Smoky Quartz and Diamond Albion Ring

David Yurman

Pre-Owned David Yurman Smoky Quartz and Diamond Albion Ring

$ 499 $ 975
Pre-Owned Scott Kay Black Sapphire Cross RingPre-Owned Scott Kay Black Sapphire Cross Ring

Scott Kay

Pre-Owned Scott Kay Black Sapphire Cross Ring

$ 255 $ 517
Pre-Owned John Hardy Leather and Chalcedony Bead Dot BraceletPre-Owned John Hardy Leather and Chalcedony Bead Dot Bracelet

John Hardy

Pre-Owned John Hardy Leather and Chalcedony Bead Dot Bracelet

$ 398 $ 795
Pre-Owned Damiani Diamond Hoop EarringsPre-Owned Damiani Diamond Hoop Earrings

Damiani

Pre-Owned Damiani Diamond Hoop Earrings

$ 1,750 $ 3,500
Pre-Owned David Yurman Diamond Noblesse CuffPre-Owned David Yurman Diamond Noblesse Cuff

David Yurman

Pre-Owned David Yurman Diamond Noblesse Cuff

$ 535 $ 895
Pre-Owned Bvlgari Sicaldi Circles PendantPre-Owned Bvlgari Sicaldi Circles Pendant

Bvlgari

Pre-Owned Bvlgari Sicaldi Circles Pendant

$ 2,875 $ 5,695
Pre-Owned Chanel Vintage Pendant NecklacePre-Owned Chanel Vintage Pendant Necklace

Chanel

Pre-Owned Chanel Vintage Pendant Necklace

$ 1,075 $ 1,575
Pre-Owned Diamond Link BraceletPre-Owned Diamond Link Bracelet
sold

Store 5a Luxury Preowned Goods

Pre-Owned Diamond Link Bracelet

$ 5,825 $ 12,700
Pre-Owned Diamond Cross NecklacePre-Owned Diamond Cross Necklace
sold

Store 5a Luxury Preowned Goods

Pre-Owned Diamond Cross Necklace

$ 495 $ 975
Pre-Owned Round Brilliant Diamond Stud EarringsPre-Owned Round Brilliant Diamond Stud Earrings

Store 5a Luxury Preowned Goods

Pre-Owned Round Brilliant Diamond Stud Earrings

$ 525 $ 1,065
Pre-Owned David Yurman Chalcedony and Diamond Collar NecklacePre-Owned David Yurman Chalcedony and Diamond Collar Necklace

David Yurman

Pre-Owned David Yurman Chalcedony and Diamond Collar Necklace

$ 3,600 $ 8,900
Pre-Owned John Hardy Palu Medium Hoop EarringsPre-Owned John Hardy Palu Medium Hoop Earrings

Store 5a Luxury Preowned Goods

Pre-Owned John Hardy Palu Medium Hoop Earrings

$ 585 $ 975
Pre-Owned Lagos Caviar Rope ChainPre-Owned Lagos Caviar Rope Chain

Lagos

Pre-Owned Lagos Caviar Rope Chain

$ 285 $ 574
Pre-Owned John Hardy Dot Stud EarringsPre-Owned John Hardy Dot Stud Earrings

John Hardy

Pre-Owned John Hardy Dot Stud Earrings

$ 250 $ 525
Pre-Owned Tiffany & Co. Somerset BanglePre-Owned Tiffany & Co. Somerset Bangle
sold

Tiffany & Co.

Pre-Owned Tiffany & Co. Somerset Bangle

$ 385 $ 640
Pre-Owned David Yurman Diamond Double Wheat Chain with DonutPre-Owned David Yurman Diamond Double Wheat Chain with Donut
sold

David Yurman

Pre-Owned David Yurman Diamond Double Wheat Chain with Donut

$ 585 $ 980
Pre-Owned Grey Pearl RingPre-Owned Grey Pearl Ring

Store 5a Luxury Preowned Goods

Pre-Owned Grey Pearl Ring

$ 625 $ 1,450
Pre-Owned Round Brilliant Diamond Stud EarringsPre-Owned Round Brilliant Diamond Stud Earrings

Store 5a Luxury Preowned Goods

Pre-Owned Round Brilliant Diamond Stud Earrings

$ 1,245 $ 2,490
Pre-Owned David Yurman Gold Dome CuffPre-Owned David Yurman Gold Dome Cuff

David Yurman

Pre-Owned David Yurman Gold Dome Cuff

$ 495 $ 825
Pre-Owned Tiffany & Co. Return to Tiffany Double Blue Heart Tag PendantPre-Owned Tiffany & Co. Return to Tiffany Double Blue Heart Tag Pendant
sold

Tiffany & Co.

Pre-Owned Tiffany & Co. Return to Tiffany Double Blue Heart Tag Pendant

$ 210 $ 300
Pre-Owned Tiffany & Co. Hardware Ball BraceletPre-Owned Tiffany & Co. Hardware Ball Bracelet

Tiffany & Co.

Pre-Owned Tiffany & Co. Hardware Ball Bracelet

$ 280 $ 350
Pre-Owned David Yurman Large Cable Infinity Knot RingPre-Owned David Yurman Large Cable Infinity Knot Ring

David Yurman

Pre-Owned David Yurman Large Cable Infinity Knot Ring

$ 495 $ 975
Pre-Owned Louis Vuitton Teddy Bear Brooch SetPre-Owned Louis Vuitton Teddy Bear Brooch Set

Louis Vuitton

Pre-Owned Louis Vuitton Teddy Bear Brooch Set

$ 415

Recently viewed