Pre Owned Luxury Jewelry

Find pre-owned jewelry from luxury brands like David Yurman, Cartier, Ippolita, Tiffany, and more. 

Browse our fine jewelry below or at one of our Columbus stores today. Looking to make your purchase more affordable? Learn about our buying services. 
Pre-Owned Diamond Hoop EarringsPre-Owned Diamond Hoop Earrings

STORE 5a Luxury Preowned Goods

Pre-Owned Diamond Hoop Earrings

$ 1,450 $ 3,530
Pre-Owned Tiffany & Co. Graffiti X PendantPre-Owned Tiffany & Co. Graffiti X Pendant
sold

Tiffany & Co.

Pre-Owned Tiffany & Co. Graffiti X Pendant

$ 495 $ 850
Pre-Owned Lagos Amethyst and Pearl EarringsPre-Owned Lagos Amethyst and Pearl Earrings

Lagos

Pre-Owned Lagos Amethyst and Pearl Earrings

$ 325 $ 650
Pre-Owned Beaded ChainPre-Owned Beaded Chain

STORE 5a Luxury Preowned Goods

Pre-Owned Beaded Chain

$ 310 $ 620
Pre-Owned David Yurman Blue Topaz Confetti CuffPre-Owned David Yurman Blue Topaz Confetti Cuff

David Yurman

Pre-Owned David Yurman Blue Topaz Confetti Cuff

$ 795 $ 1,350
Pre-Owned Katy Briscoe Turquoise EarringsPre-Owned Katy Briscoe Turquoise Earrings

Katy Briscoe

Pre-Owned Katy Briscoe Turquoise Earrings

$ 4,175 $ 7,800
Pre-Owned Effy Watercolors PendantPre-Owned Effy Watercolors Pendant

Effy

Pre-Owned Effy Watercolors Pendant

$ 1,550 $ 2,600
Pre-Owned David Yurman Long Figaro NecklacePre-Owned David Yurman Long Figaro Necklace

David Yurman

Pre-Owned David Yurman Long Figaro Necklace

$ 895 $ 1,450
Pre-Owned Akoya Pearl and Diamond Stud EarringsPre-Owned Akoya Pearl and Diamond Stud Earrings

STORE 5a Luxury Preowned Goods

Pre-Owned Akoya Pearl and Diamond Stud Earrings

$ 625 $ 1,050
Pre-Owned Garnet and Diamond RingPre-Owned Garnet and Diamond Ring

STORE 5a Luxury Preowned Goods

Pre-Owned Garnet and Diamond Ring

$ 995 $ 2,150
Pre-Owned Filigree Hoop EarringsPre-Owned Filigree Hoop Earrings

STORE 5a Luxury Preowned Goods

Pre-Owned Filigree Hoop Earrings

$ 435 $ 875
Pre-Owned Square Ribbed EarringsPre-Owned Square Ribbed Earrings

STORE 5a Luxury Preowned Goods

Pre-Owned Square Ribbed Earrings

$ 1,120 $ 2,245
Pre-Owned Herringbone ChainPre-Owned Herringbone Chain

STORE 5a Luxury Preowned Goods

Pre-Owned Herringbone Chain

$ 2,535 $ 4,525
Pre-Owned Tiffany & Co. Oval Link ChainPre-Owned Tiffany & Co. Oval Link Chain

Tiffany & Co.

Pre-Owned Tiffany & Co. Oval Link Chain

$ 375 $ 625
Pre-Owned John Hardy Hammered Carved Chain Hoop EarringsPre-Owned John Hardy Hammered Carved Chain Hoop Earrings

John Hardy

Pre-Owned John Hardy Hammered Carved Chain Hoop Earrings

$ 195 $ 350
Pre-Owned Blue Topaz and Diamond Eternity RingPre-Owned Blue Topaz and Diamond Eternity Ring

STORE 5a Luxury Preowned Goods

Pre-Owned Blue Topaz and Diamond Eternity Ring

$ 1,995 $ 3,675
Pre-Owned David Yurman Garnet Classic Cable RingPre-Owned David Yurman Garnet Classic Cable Ring

David Yurman

Pre-Owned David Yurman Garnet Classic Cable Ring

$ 245 $ 450
Pre-Owned Fancy Link Sliding ChainPre-Owned Fancy Link Sliding Chain

STORE 5a Luxury Preowned Goods

Pre-Owned Fancy Link Sliding Chain

$ 465 $ 930
Pre-Owned Buttercup Diamond Stud EarringsPre-Owned Buttercup Diamond Stud Earrings

STORE 5a Luxury Preowned Goods

Pre-Owned Buttercup Diamond Stud Earrings

$ 365 $ 725
Pre-Owned Diamond PendantPre-Owned Diamond Pendant

STORE 5a Luxury Preowned Goods

Pre-Owned Diamond Pendant

$ 2,495 $ 5,000
Pre-Owned Tiffany & Co. Return to Tiffany Heart Tag Toggle BraceletPre-Owned Tiffany & Co. Return to Tiffany Heart Tag Toggle Bracelet

Tiffany & Co.

Pre-Owned Tiffany & Co. Return to Tiffany Heart Tag Toggle Bracelet

$ 345 $ 575
Pre-Owned David Yurman Long Box Link ChainPre-Owned David Yurman Long Box Link Chain

David Yurman

Pre-Owned David Yurman Long Box Link Chain

$ 525 $ 880
Pre-Owned Lagos Black Onyx Caviar RingPre-Owned Lagos Black Onyx Caviar Ring

Lagos

Pre-Owned Lagos Black Onyx Caviar Ring

$ 395 $ 800
Pre-Owned David Yurman Blue Topaz and Diamond Petite Wheaton RingPre-Owned David Yurman Blue Topaz and Diamond Petite Wheaton Ring

David Yurman

Pre-Owned David Yurman Blue Topaz and Diamond Petite Wheaton Ring

$ 375 $ 625
Pre-Owned Lagos Caviar BraceletPre-Owned Lagos Caviar Bracelet

Lagos

Pre-Owned Lagos Caviar Bracelet

$ 350
Pre-Owned Vintage Diamond PendantPre-Owned Vintage Diamond Pendant

STORE 5a Luxury Preowned Goods

Pre-Owned Vintage Diamond Pendant

$ 320 $ 635
Pre-Owned Diamond Tied Strands NecklacePre-Owned Diamond Tied Strands Necklace

STORE 5a Luxury Preowned Goods

Pre-Owned Diamond Tied Strands Necklace

$ 5,125 $ 10,250
Pre-Owned Citrine and Madeira Citrine EarringsPre-Owned Citrine and Madeira Citrine Earrings

STORE 5a Luxury Preowned Goods

Pre-Owned Citrine and Madeira Citrine Earrings

$ 795 $ 1,900
Pre-Owned Stephen Webster Cats Eye Knuckle RingPre-Owned Stephen Webster Cats Eye Knuckle Ring

Stephen Webster

Pre-Owned Stephen Webster Cats Eye Knuckle Ring

$ 425 $ 825
Pre-Owned Stephen Webster Blue Sapphire and Turquoise EarringsPre-Owned Stephen Webster Blue Sapphire and Turquoise Earrings

Stephen Webster

Pre-Owned Stephen Webster Blue Sapphire and Turquoise Earrings

$ 1,100
Pre-Owned Judith Ripka Diamond CuffPre-Owned Judith Ripka Diamond Cuff

Judith Ripka

Pre-Owned Judith Ripka Diamond Cuff

$ 695
Pre-Owned David Yurman Lemon Quartz and Diamond Albion PendantPre-Owned David Yurman Lemon Quartz and Diamond Albion Pendant

David Yurman

Pre-Owned David Yurman Lemon Quartz and Diamond Albion Pendant

$ 525 $ 695
Pre-Owned John Hardy Kali Marquise RingPre-Owned John Hardy Kali Marquise Ring

John Hardy

Pre-Owned John Hardy Kali Marquise Ring

$ 275
Pre-Owned Ruby and Diamond RingPre-Owned Ruby and Diamond Ring

STORE 5a Luxury Preowned Goods

Pre-Owned Ruby and Diamond Ring

$ 1,895 $ 4,420
Pre-Owned Polished Groove BanglePre-Owned Polished Groove Bangle

STORE 5a Luxury Preowned Goods

Pre-Owned Polished Groove Bangle

$ 905 $ 1,815
Pre-Owned Wire NecklacePre-Owned Wire Necklace

STORE 5a Luxury Preowned Goods

Pre-Owned Wire Necklace

$ 395 $ 775
Pre-Owned Baguette Diamond RingPre-Owned Baguette Diamond Ring

STORE 5a Luxury Preowned Goods

Pre-Owned Baguette Diamond Ring

$ 3,950 $ 7,900
Pre-Owned London Blue Topaz and Diamond RingPre-Owned London Blue Topaz and Diamond Ring

STORE 5a Luxury Preowned Goods

Pre-Owned London Blue Topaz and Diamond Ring

$ 1,495 $ 2,495
Pre-Owned Diamond EarringsPre-Owned Diamond Earrings

STORE 5a Luxury Preowned Goods

Pre-Owned Diamond Earrings

$ 6,895 $ 13,855
Pre-Owned Jade Cabochon RingPre-Owned Jade Cabochon Ring

STORE 5a Luxury Preowned Goods

Pre-Owned Jade Cabochon Ring

$ 1,675 $ 2,800

Recently viewed