Pre Owned Luxury Jewelry

Find pre-owned jewelry from luxury brands like David Yurman, Cartier, Ippolita, Tiffany, and more. 

Browse our fine jewelry below or at one of our Columbus stores today. Looking to make your purchase more affordable? Learn about our buying services. 
Pre-owned Stephen Webster Crystal Haze RingPre-owned Stephen Webster Crystal Haze Ring

STEPHEN WEBSTER

Pre-owned Stephen Webster Crystal Haze Ring

$ 250 $ 425
Pre-Owned Vintage Style Carnelian RingPre-Owned Vintage Style Carnelian Ring

STORE 5a

Pre-Owned Vintage Style Carnelian Ring

$ 199 $ 475
Pre-Owned Ladies Coral Fancy RingPre-Owned Ladies Coral Fancy Ring

STORE 5a

Pre-Owned Ladies Coral Fancy Ring

$ 575 $ 1,350
Pre-Owned Smoky Quartz Bead NecklacePre-Owned Smoky Quartz Bead Necklace

STORE 5a

Pre-Owned Smoky Quartz Bead Necklace

$ 499 $ 1,100
Pre-Owned CufflinksPre-Owned Cufflinks

STORE 5a

Pre-Owned Cufflinks

$ 1,225 $ 3,450
Pre-Owned Diamond Tennis BraceletPre-Owned Diamond Tennis Bracelet

STORE 5a

Pre-Owned Diamond Tennis Bracelet

$ 4,999 $ 10,060
Pre-Owned Tiffany & Co. Diamond Heart PendantPre-Owned Tiffany & Co. Diamond Heart Pendant

TIFFANY & CO.

Pre-Owned Tiffany & Co. Diamond Heart Pendant

$ 950 $ 2,500
Pre-Owned Pianegonda Diamond RingPre-Owned Pianegonda Diamond Ring

PIANEGONDA

Pre-Owned Pianegonda Diamond Ring

$ 1,250 $ 2,575
Pre-Owned Barry Brinker NecklacePre-Owned Barry Brinker Necklace

BARRY BRINKER

Pre-Owned Barry Brinker Necklace

$ 250 $ 500
Pre-Owned Tacori London Blue Topaz EarringsPre-Owned Tacori London Blue Topaz Earrings

TACORI

Pre-Owned Tacori London Blue Topaz Earrings

$ 1,060 $ 2,120
Pre-Owned Gents Diamond RingPre-Owned Gents Diamond Ring

STORE 5a

Pre-Owned Gents Diamond Ring

$ 3,950 $ 10,765
Pre-Owned Pyrope Garnet RingPre-Owned Pyrope Garnet Ring

STORE 5a

Pre-Owned Pyrope Garnet Ring

$ 999 $ 2,475
Pre-Owned Sapphire and Diamond RingPre-Owned Sapphire and Diamond Ring

STORE 5a

Pre-Owned Sapphire and Diamond Ring

$ 4,225 $ 7,700
Pre-Owned Pearl and Diamond PendantPre-Owned Pearl and Diamond Pendant

STORE 5a

Pre-Owned Pearl and Diamond Pendant

$ 975 $ 2,150
Pre-Owned Synthetic Emerald and Moissanite EarringsPre-Owned Synthetic Emerald and Moissanite Earrings

STORE 5a

Pre-Owned Synthetic Emerald and Moissanite Earrings

$ 650 $ 1,300
Pre-Owned Custom Spanish Coin and Diamond EnhancerPre-Owned Custom Spanish Coin and Diamond Enhancer

STORE 5a

Pre-Owned Custom Spanish Coin and Diamond Enhancer

$ 5,500 $ 11,000
Pre-Owned Diamond and Sapphire RingPre-Owned Diamond and Sapphire Ring

STORE 5a

Pre-Owned Diamond and Sapphire Ring

$ 2,400 $ 5,310
Pre-Owned Ruby and Diamond RingPre-Owned Ruby and Diamond Ring

STORE 5a

Pre-Owned Ruby and Diamond Ring

$ 850 $ 1,940
Pre-Owned David Yurman Lemon Citrine RingPre-Owned David Yurman Lemon Citrine Ring

DAVID YURMAN

Pre-Owned David Yurman Lemon Citrine Ring

$ 1,100 $ 1,650
Pre-Owned Ruby and Diamond RingPre-Owned Ruby and Diamond Ring

STORE 5a

Pre-Owned Ruby and Diamond Ring

$ 14,800 $ 25,725
Pre-Owned Tiffany & Co. Paloma Picasso Heart PendantPre-Owned Tiffany & Co. Paloma Picasso Heart Pendant

TIFFANY & CO.

Pre-Owned Tiffany & Co. Paloma Picasso Heart Pendant

$ 1,500 $ 2,500
Pre-Owned Kieselstein Heart PendantPre-Owned Kieselstein Heart Pendant

KIESELSTEIN

Pre-Owned Kieselstein Heart Pendant

$ 1,999 $ 5,900
Pre-Owned Rubellite Tourmaline RingPre-Owned Rubellite Tourmaline Ring

STORE 5a

Pre-Owned Rubellite Tourmaline Ring

$ 7,965 $ 15,930
Pre-Owned Amethyst Fashion RingPre-Owned Amethyst Fashion Ring

STORE 5a

Pre-Owned Amethyst Fashion Ring

$ 599 $ 1,670
Pre-Owned Louis Vuitton Petite Fleur RingPre-Owned Louis Vuitton Petite Fleur Ring

LOUIS VUITTON

Pre-Owned Louis Vuitton Petite Fleur Ring

$ 1,550 $ 3,000
Pre-Owned Diamond Heart RingPre-Owned Diamond Heart Ring

STORE 5a

Pre-Owned Diamond Heart Ring

$ 95 $ 365
Pre-Owned Green Onyx and Sapphire BraceletPre-Owned Green Onyx and Sapphire Bracelet

STORE 5a

Pre-Owned Green Onyx and Sapphire Bracelet

$ 1,150 $ 4,490
Pre-Owned Synthetic Spinel PendantPre-Owned Synthetic Spinel Pendant

STORE 5a

Pre-Owned Synthetic Spinel Pendant

$ 1,090 $ 2,490
Pre-Owned Star Sapphire and Diamond RingPre-Owned Star Sapphire and Diamond Ring

STORE 5a

Pre-Owned Star Sapphire and Diamond Ring

$ 18,900 $ 47,585
Pre-Owned Le Vian Bird Pin & EnhancerPre-Owned Le Vian Bird Pin & Enhancer

LE VIAN

Pre-Owned Le Vian Bird Pin & Enhancer

$ 1,230 $ 4,750
Pre-Owned Hoop EarringsPre-Owned Hoop Earrings

STORE 5a

Pre-Owned Hoop Earrings

$ 999 $ 2,525
Pre-Owned Roberto Coin Woven CuffPre-Owned Roberto Coin Woven Cuff

ROBERTO COIN

Pre-Owned Roberto Coin Woven Cuff

$ 625 $ 1,250
Pre-Owned Synthetic Ruby RingPre-Owned Synthetic Ruby Ring

STORE 5a

Pre-Owned Synthetic Ruby Ring

$ 420 $ 1,475
Pre-Owned Diamond Hoop EarringsPre-Owned Diamond Hoop Earrings

STORE 5a

Pre-Owned Diamond Hoop Earrings

$ 1,995 $ 5,925
Pre-Owned Brown and White Diamond Pave CuffPre-Owned Brown and White Diamond Pave Cuff

STORE 5a

Pre-Owned Brown and White Diamond Pave Cuff

$ 4,450 $ 12,150
Pre-Owned Judith Ripka Smoky Quartz RingPre-Owned Judith Ripka Smoky Quartz Ring

JUDITH RIPKA

Pre-Owned Judith Ripka Smoky Quartz Ring

$ 1,375 $ 2,750
Pre-Owned Ladies Fancy Diamond RingPre-Owned Ladies Fancy Diamond Ring

STORE 5a

Pre-Owned Ladies Fancy Diamond Ring

$ 999 $ 2,195
Pre-Owned Ladies Rutilated Kunzite Spodumene RingPre-Owned Ladies Rutilated Kunzite Spodumene Ring

STORE 5a

Pre-Owned Ladies Rutilated Kunzite Spodumene Ring

$ 2,400 $ 5,500
Pre-Owned Ladies Vintage Emerald and Diamond RingPre-Owned Ladies Vintage Emerald and Diamond Ring

STORE 5a

Pre-Owned Ladies Vintage Emerald and Diamond Ring

$ 2,999 $ 6,500
Pre-Owned Gold Dot RingPre-Owned Gold Dot Ring

STORE 5a

Pre-Owned Gold Dot Ring

$ 525 $ 1,325

Recently viewed